Parenting - Putting the Children First
Just quickly …
The relevant law
Parenting disputes are governed by Part VII of the Family Law Act. The Act states that the best interests of the children are paramount when determining parenting arrangements. Importantly, section 60CC of the Act states the primary considerations when determining the best interests of children are the benefits of having “a meaningful relationship” with both parents, and the need to always protect children from physical or psychological harm (including being exposed to abuse and family violence).
When determining what is best for children, the need to protect children from harm will be given greater weight than the need to have a meaningful relationship with both parents. Of course, there needs to be a real and unacceptable risk to the children before time with the other parent can be suspended or strictly limited.
There are also many other secondary considerations when deciding parenting matters.
Equal time
Without court orders to the contrary, both parents enjoy equal shared parenting responsibility for their children. This means both parents should be involved in long-term parenting decisions including where the children live and attend school, their legal name, their religion, and medical treatments.
If there is equal parenting responsibility, then a court must consider whether it is appropriate to make orders for equal shared care or at least substantial and significant time with each parent (section 65DAA of the Act).
What the children want
If you and the other parent cannot agree, and your matter goes to court, your children’s wishes about where they live and how much time they spend with each parent can be taken into account. Importantly, your children’s preferences are only one of a number of factors that the court will take into account.
There’s no hard and fast rule (or age) about when your children get to decide parenting arrangements. Generally, however, children’s views are given greater weight depending on their age and level of maturity.
There are very strict rules about how the children’s views can be made known to the court. We strongly advise against parents ever talking to the children directly about what they want. This can inadvertently make children feel like they have to choose, and children are generally not emotionally mature enough to navigate such highly emotional issues without serious, long-term emotional damage.
The best way for children to share their preferences for parenting arrangements is with the help of an appropriately qualified social worker or psychologist. These type of family reports (where experts engage with the children directly as well as with each parent and any other members of the two households) are regularly required by the courts when determining parenting disputes. However, a lawyer can help you arrange such a report before going to court, to help both parents agree to parenting arrangements between them without damaging and often costly litigation.
Need more information?
We have published several articles about all areas of family law including parenting disputes, which you can find here.
Alternatively, contact us for a free telephone consult, or book a no-obligation meeting with an experienced family lawyer.
Parental alienation
Parental alienation is where one parent influences their child’s views about the other parent, and their wishes about parenting arrangements. Parental alienation is not always intentional: children are often heavily influenced by their parents’ actions in relation to the other parent including their general demeanour, off-hand comments, or by overhearing their parents’ arguments.
Research has shown that children often lack the maturity needed to navigate their own relationships between adults who are in conflict. The result can be children emotionally aligning themselves with one parent over the other, as the only way they know how to cope. The effects of parental alienation are usually very devastating on children, and can result in symptoms including night terrors, bed-wetting, poor schooling, bullying and other anti-social behaviours, and problems adjusting to their own adult life in later years leading to their own inability to build strong relationships, drug use, alcoholism, and crime.
Formalising parenting arrangements
Agreed parenting arrangements can be informal (e.g. worked out on an ongoing basis through parents negotiating with each other), or formalised through a parenting plan or court orders made by consent.
A parenting plan must be in writing and must be signed by both parents, but it is not binding. Nevertheless, if a parenting plan has been in place for some time, it can be given preference by a court if a dispute arises.
A family lawyer can help you draft comprehensive parenting orders which can then be formalised by the court by consent. Orders are binding, so it is important that you have a lawyer help you draft them. Poorly worded parenting orders can be difficult to set aside, if they have unintended consequences or circumstances change.
About Shorestone Legal
Shorestone Legal is based in Banyo, on Brisbane’s Northside. We practice in the areas of Family Law, Wills and Estates.
Our team of family law solicitors are experts in all areas of Family Law including separation and divorce, property division, financial settlements, parenting arrangements, and binding financial agreements.
We are experienced in last will and testament, and estate administration including application for probate, or contesting a will.
We achieve best outcomes for our clients with our knowledge, experience and understanding of each client’s unique situation.